The ultimate scoreboard of truth.

A Wikipedia of arguments. Every belief system gets one yes/no question. R3fute collects the strongest answers on each side, threads every reply to them, and keeps track of which answers still stand.

QuestionIs Islam true?
Yes2 stand

The objection assumes a premise it never supports.

Holding up

The cited verse is read without its context.

Unanswered
No1 stands

The text contradicts itself on this point.

Answered

The argument from historical record.

Awaiting grade
Core principle

Truth by elimination.

R3fute doesn't try to prove beliefs true. Every position is the default until it's refuted. Each one stands open to attack, and whatever is still standing after every attack is a candidate for truth.

The last man standing.

  1. P1The burden is on the argument: it succeeds only if every premise it needs is established and its reasoning is valid.
  2. P2A reply doesn't have to prove its own side. Showing that one needed premise is unsupported, or that the reasoning fails, defeats the argument.
  3. โˆดAn answer stands until a reply defeats it, whichever side it's on. The answers still standing are what the question comes down to.
How it's organized

One question. Two sides. Threads all the way down.

Is Islam true?
Yes
Answer: an objection's key premise has no evidence
Reply โ†’ Reply โ†’ Reply โ€ฆ
No
Answer: the argument from contradiction
Reply โ†’ Reply โ€ฆ
Rulings live inside their tradition: "Is shrimp halal?" sits within "Is Islam true?"
What the verdicts mean

"Stands" means unanswered so far, not proven.

Unanswered

No one has replied yet, so it stands.

Holding up

It has been challenged, but no challenge both answers it adequately and still stands itself. It stands.

Awaiting grade

Someone replied, and AI hasn't graded the reply yet. It stands until a reply is graded adequate.

Answered

A reply answers it adequately and still stands itself, so it no longer stands.

Features

Built so good arguments don't disappear.

One box

Write your point. AI works out which question it answers, which side it's on, and where it goes in the thread. X links and videos go through the same box.

Deductive form

Before anything is posted, AI restates it as premises and a conclusion, so everyone can see exactly what is being claimed.

Every reply graded

Each reply is graded adequate or inadequate against what it answers, and the grade is clearly labeled as AI.

Debate videos

Paste a debate. AI transcribes it, finds each argument with its timestamp, and places every one under its question.

Star arguments

The single defeater the other side never answered is marked as the star argument. Each layer of replies has its own star.

No login wall

Guests can post as "Refuter 1234". Members sign in with X, email, phone or a passkey.

Starting with religion, built to grow into philosophy and politics.

Founded by Samir Nader and Yasser Jaghoori.